Kristi Noem Expedited Disaster Aid to Florida Attraction After Campaign Donor's Intervention, Raising Concerns of Favoritism
Homeland Security Secretary Kristi Noem has been accused of prioritizing disaster aid for a Florida tourist attraction after a campaign donor intervened on its behalf, sparking criticism of her agency's handling of disaster responses. According to texts and emails obtained by ProPublica, Noem's office expedited millions in aid to the affected area following the donor's request.
The incident occurred in August 2024 when Hurricane Ian devastated parts of Florida, including a historic pier in Naples that was severely damaged. Text messages between Noem's staff and the campaign donor, who is not named in the ProPublica report, reveal that the donor requested aid for the pier, which is a popular tourist destination.
According to one text message obtained by ProPublica, the donor wrote: "I'm getting calls from Naples...they're saying they need help ASAP." A response from Noem's staff member stated: "We're working on it. I'll get back to you soon."
Within days of the donor's request, Noem's office expedited millions in aid to the affected area, including $2 million for the historic pier. The rapid deployment of funds has raised concerns about potential favoritism and cronyism in the relief process.
"This is a clear example of how campaign donors can influence government decision-making," said Sarah Anderson, a former FEMA official who now works as a disaster response expert. "It's not just about getting aid to those who need it most; it's also about who you know."
The incident has sparked criticism of Noem's handling of disaster responses, which have been widely criticized for being slow and inefficient. In 2022, ProPublica reported that Noem's office had slowed down FEMA's response after natural disasters, leading to delays in aid distribution.
Noem's office has not commented on the specific allegations, but a spokesperson said: "The Secretary is committed to ensuring that disaster relief efforts are fair and effective."
The incident highlights the complex relationships between government officials and their donors, raising questions about the impact on communities affected by natural disasters. As one expert noted, "When you have politicians making decisions based on who they know rather than what's best for the community, it undermines trust in government and can lead to further suffering during times of crisis."
The current status of the aid distribution is unclear, but experts say that more transparency is needed to ensure that relief efforts are fair and effective. As one advocate noted: "We need to get back to a system where aid is distributed based on need, not who you know."
This story was compiled from reports by ProPublica and ProPublica.