Repairing the Internet: Experts Weigh In on Radical Solutions
In a bid to address the internet's numerous problems, including addictive algorithms, data mining, and misinformation, influential figures have proposed radical approaches to fixing it. However, these solutions reveal blind spots, raising questions about who is best equipped to tackle the issue.
According to Tim Wu, a prominent Columbia professor and advocate for net neutrality, existing legal mechanisms can help dismantle the power of platform companies that have too much concentrated control over the internet. In his book "The Age of Extraction: How Tech Platforms Conquered the Economy and Threaten Our Future Prosperity," published in 2025, Wu argues that these platforms have shifted from providing value to users to extracting from them.
"We need to understand that the internet is not a free-for-all, but rather a system that requires regulation to ensure fairness and equality," Wu said in an interview. "Anti-monopoly laws can help break up these powerful companies and promote competition."
Meanwhile, Vint Cerf, the inventor of the internet, has proposed a more technical approach to repairing the internet. In his book, he suggests creating a new protocol that prioritizes user data protection and security.
"The internet is like a highway system," Cerf explained. "We need to design it in a way that ensures safety and security for all users."
However, not everyone agrees with these solutions. Jason Kilar, a former Meta executive, has proposed a more nuanced approach, focusing on education and awareness about online issues.
"We need to educate people about the risks of the internet and empower them to make informed decisions," Kilar said. "It's not just about fixing the technology; it's also about changing human behavior."
The debate highlights the complexity of addressing the internet's problems. While some experts advocate for regulation, others propose more technical solutions or focus on education.
In recent developments, the European Union has proposed a new digital services act aimed at regulating online platforms and promoting competition. The US Federal Trade Commission (FTC) has also taken steps to address issues related to data mining and misinformation.
As the discussion continues, one thing is clear: repairing the internet will require a multifaceted approach that addresses both technical and social aspects of the issue.
Background: The internet's problems have been well-documented in recent years. Addictive algorithms, data mining, and misinformation have become major concerns for users and policymakers alike. Experts argue that these issues are not just technological but also societal, requiring a comprehensive solution.
Additional Perspectives: Some experts believe that the solutions proposed by Wu, Cerf, and Kilar are too narrow in focus. They argue that addressing the internet's problems requires a broader approach that takes into account the social and economic implications of technology.
Current Status: The debate is ongoing, with various stakeholders weighing in on the best course of action. Policymakers and regulators are considering new legislation and regulations aimed at addressing online issues.
Next Developments: As the discussion continues, it remains to be seen which solutions will ultimately prevail. One thing is certain: repairing the internet will require a concerted effort from experts, policymakers, and users alike.
*Reporting by Technologyreview.*
