Osgood Perkins' Keeper: A Chilling Experiment in Horror Logic

Osgood Perkins' latest film, Keeper, has been met with mixed reviews from critics, with some praising its experimental approach to horror while others find it lacking in logic. The movie, which premiered on November 13, 2025, has been described as an "impressionistic" serial-killer film that relies heavily on creepy atmosphere rather than traditional plot development. According to Owen Gleiberman, chief film critic for Variety, Keeper feels like a "random horror mixtape" projected onto the screen by Perkins, who is known for his work on films like "Longlegs" and "Monkey." Gleiberman notes that while the movie has its disturbing moments, it ultimately feels like a collection of disparate scenes rather than a cohesive narrative. "It has disturbing scenes, but mostly it feels like the director of 'Longlegs' projecting the random horror mixtape of his brain onto the screen," Gleiberman wrote in his review. Perkins' experimental approach to filmmaking is not without precedent in the horror genre. In recent years, there has been a growing trend towards more avant-garde and unconventional horror films that prioritize atmosphere and mood over traditional plot structures. However, not all critics are convinced that Keeper is a successful example of this trend. "In theory, making an experimental movie is a bold creative act," Gleiberman notes, "though I wouldn't score their success rate at too high a percentage." Despite the mixed reviews, Keeper is likely to appeal to fans of more avant-garde horror films. The movie's use of creepy atmosphere and unsettling imagery is reminiscent of classic horror films like "The Texas Chain Saw Massacre" and "The Exorcist." Additionally, Perkins' direction has been praised for its visual style and attention to detail, which adds to the overall sense of unease and tension. As for what's next for Perkins and his team, it remains to be seen. The director has not yet announced any upcoming projects, but fans of his work will likely be eagerly awaiting his next release. In the meantime, Keeper will continue to generate buzz and debate among horror fans and critics alike. In an interview with Variety, Perkins acknowledged the challenges of making an experimental film like Keeper. "I think it's a risk that not everyone is going to be on board with," he said. "But for me, it's about pushing the boundaries of what's possible in horror and creating a sense of unease and tension that's not just about jump scares and gore." Ultimately, the success of Keeper will depend on how audiences and critics respond to its unique approach to horror. While some may find it too experimental or confusing, others may appreciate its bold creativity and willingness to take risks. As the horror genre continues to evolve and push boundaries, it will be interesting to see how Keeper fits into the larger conversation about the future of horror filmmaking.