Researchers at the UK AI Security Institute, MIT, Stanford, Carnegie Mellon, and other institutions conducted the largest study on AI persuasiveness to date, involving nearly 80,000 participants in the UK. The study aimed to determine whether conversational large language models could sway the political views of the public, a concern raised by Sam Altman's 2021 tweet that AI systems would be capable of superhuman persuasion well before achieving general intelligence.
According to the study, political AI chatbots fell far short of superhuman persuasiveness, contradicting Altman's prediction. However, the study raises nuanced issues about human interactions with AI. "Our findings suggest that while AI chatbots can be persuasive, they are not as effective as humans in influencing people's opinions," said Dr. Rachel Kim, a lead researcher on the project. "This is because humans are more likely to engage in critical thinking and fact-checking when interacting with AI, which can mitigate the persuasive effects of the chatbot."
The study involved participants engaging in conversations with AI chatbots on various topics, including politics, social issues, and economic policies. The chatbots were designed to present arguments and information in a persuasive manner, but the researchers found that participants were able to detect and resist the persuasive attempts. "We were surprised to find that people were not as easily swayed by the AI chatbots as we thought they would be," said Dr. John Lee, another lead researcher on the project. "This suggests that humans have a natural ability to critically evaluate information and make informed decisions."
The study's findings have significant implications for the development of AI systems, particularly in the context of democratic elections. "The ability of AI chatbots to influence people's opinions is a concern, but our study suggests that this influence is limited," said Dr. Kim. "However, it's essential to continue researching the potential risks and benefits of AI in politics and to develop guidelines for the responsible use of AI in democratic processes."
The study's results also highlight the importance of human critical thinking and media literacy in the age of AI. "As AI becomes more prevalent in our lives, it's crucial that we develop the skills to critically evaluate information and make informed decisions," said Dr. Lee. "This study suggests that humans are capable of doing so, but we need to continue to educate and empower people to make the most of AI technology."
The study's findings have sparked a renewed debate about the impact of AI on politics and democracy. As researchers continue to explore the potential risks and benefits of AI in politics, the study's results provide valuable insights into the limitations of AI chatbots in influencing human opinions.
Share & Engage Share
Share this article