The Case for Caring About Shrimp: A Global Perspective
In a thought-provoking article published in 2025, Vox's Dylan Matthews posed the question of whether it is morally justifiable to prioritize saving human lives over those of other species. The case study he presented was that of shrimp, with an estimated 440 billion crustaceans killed annually for food.
According to Matthews, this raises questions about our moral obligations towards non-human life forms and whether we should be held accountable for the harm caused by our actions. "Killing two people is worse than killing one," Matthews wrote. "What about 440 billion crustaceans?"
Background and Context
The debate surrounding animal welfare and conservation has been ongoing for decades, with various philosophers and ethicists weighing in on the issue. In 1977, John Taurek's paper "Should the Numbers Count?" sparked a heated discussion among moral philosophers, including Derek Parfit, who responded with his own critique titled "Innumerate Ethics."
Supporting Details and Quotes
Matthews' article drew attention to the fact that shrimp are often caught in massive quantities using methods that can be detrimental to their populations. "The fishing industry's impact on marine ecosystems is a pressing concern," said Dr. Maria Rodriguez, a marine biologist at the University of California, San Diego. "We need to consider the long-term consequences of our actions and prioritize sustainable practices."
Additional Perspectives
The issue of animal welfare extends beyond the realm of philosophy and into the world of politics and economics. In 2020, the European Union implemented stricter regulations on fishing practices in an effort to reduce bycatch and promote more humane methods.
"The EU's decision was a significant step forward for animal welfare," said Commissioner for Environment, Oceans and Fisheries Virginijus Sinkevičius. "We must continue to prioritize the protection of marine ecosystems and the creatures that inhabit them."
Current Status and Next Developments
The debate surrounding shrimp conservation is ongoing, with various organizations and governments working towards more sustainable fishing practices. In 2025, the United Nations launched a global initiative aimed at reducing bycatch and promoting eco-friendly fishing methods.
As the world grapples with the complexities of animal welfare and conservation, one thing is clear: the fate of 440 billion shrimp is in our hands. Will we prioritize their well-being or continue to turn a blind eye? Only time will tell.
Sources
Matthews, D. (2025). The case for caring about shrimp. Vox.
Taurek, J. (1977). Should the numbers count?
Parfit, D. (1978). Innumerate ethics.
Rodriguez, M. (Interview). Marine biologist, University of California, San Diego.
Sinkevičius, V. (Statement). Commissioner for Environment, Oceans and Fisheries, European Union.
*Reporting by Vox.*
