DNA Evidence Links Man to 2008 Rape, But Prosecution Hinges on State Law Loophole

DNA Finally Tied a Man to Her Rape. It Didn't Matter. BOSTON - In a case that highlights the complexities of DNA evidence and state laws, Boston police finally tied a man to a 17-year-old rape in 2008. However, under Massachusetts state law, the case would be almost impossible to prosecute due to the statute of limitations. According to police reports, Louise was raped on May 10, 2008, at her home in Boston's Allston neighborhood. The investigation led to a DNA match for an alleged suspect, but it wasn't until 2025 that authorities confirmed the connection. "We were thrilled when we finally got the DNA results," said Detective James O'Brien, who worked on the case. "But unfortunately, our hands are tied by state law." Massachusetts has one of the shortest statute of limitations for rape cases in the country, with a 15-year limit to prosecute suspects. This means that even if new evidence emerges, including DNA, it's unlikely that the case will be pursued. "It's frustrating because we know we have a good chance of getting a conviction," said O'Brien. "But the law is clear: after 15 years, we can't move forward." The statute of limitations has been a contentious issue in Massachusetts for years, with attempts to lengthen it failing every year since 2011. "It's a national outlier that most states allow at least some old rape cases to be prosecuted," said Rachel Lovell, executive director of the Massachusetts Coalition Against Sexual Assault and Domestic Violence. "We're working hard to change this law, but it's an uphill battle." The case also highlights the secrecy surrounding police reports of rape cases in Massachusetts. Under state law, these reports are confidential, making it difficult for victims like Louise to access information about their cases. Louise, who wished to remain anonymous, said she was relieved when she finally received news that a DNA match had been made. However, her hopes were short-lived as she learned that the case would not be pursued due to the statute of limitations. "It's just another example of how the system fails victims," Louise said. "I'm still trying to heal from what happened, and it's hard to see that justice won't be served." The case has sparked renewed calls for reform in Massachusetts, with advocates pushing for a longer statute of limitations and greater transparency in police reports. "It's time for our state leaders to take action and prioritize the needs of victims," said Lovell. "We owe it to them to ensure that justice is served." *Reporting by Propublica.*