According to Ars Technica, the games that truly stood out this year were those that emerged as surprises. These included a roguelike puzzle game defying easy categorization, a challenging mountainous walking simulator, a Geometry Wars-inspired title hailed as the best in years, and a mini-game collection exploring the complexities of adolescence.

"We were really impressed by the breadth of experiences this year," said an Ars Technica spokesperson. "While the big franchises delivered as expected, it was the innovative and unexpected titles that truly captured our attention."

The inclusion of Civilization 7 marks another strong showing for the franchise, which has consistently earned high scores since its initial release in 1991. Avowed, the fantasy RPG, was praised for its immersive world-building and engaging combat mechanics. Doom: The Dark Ages, the latest installment in the iconic first-person shooter series, was lauded for its intense action and stunning visuals.

The unexpected success stories, however, represent a shift in the gaming landscape, with smaller, independent developers making a significant impact. The roguelike puzzle game, for example, was noted for its unique blend of genres and challenging gameplay. The mountainous walking simulator, described as "gonzo and punishing," offered a distinct and memorable experience.

Looking ahead to 2026, Ars Technica anticipates another year of significant releases, with Grand Theft Auto 6 leading the charge. The industry is also preparing for other big-budget projects, promising a competitive and exciting year for gamers. The full list of Ars Technica's top 20 games of 2025 is available on their website.