According to Ars Technica, the games that truly distinguished themselves in 2025 were those that emerged as surprises. These titles spanned a variety of genres, from roguelike puzzle games defying easy categorization to a challenging mountainous walking simulator. One standout was hailed as the best Geometry Wars clone in recent memory, while another offered a poignant exploration of adolescence through a series of mini-games.

The inclusion of Civilization 7 marks another strong showing for the franchise, which has consistently earned critical acclaim since its debut in 1991. Avowed, a new IP, also made the list. Doom: The Dark Ages continues the legacy of the Doom franchise, known for its fast-paced action and demonic themes, reminiscent of its groundbreaking origins in the early 1990s.

Notably absent from the list was Grand Theft Auto 6, which Ars Technica had previously anticipated as a major contender. However, the game's delay into 2026 prevented it from being considered for this year's ranking.

Looking ahead to 2026, Ars Technica anticipates another year filled with high-profile releases, with Grand Theft Auto 6 expected to be a dominant force in the industry. The publication suggests that if 2025 is any indication, the coming year will also bring forth a new wave of unexpected and innovative titles.