Crene Logo
ScenariosClustersFactorsDataAPIMethodology
Crene
Platform
ScenariosThesis decompositionsContinuous factor maps
Data
MethodologyAPIDataset
Company
About
Explore
ScenariosDataClustersFactorsAbout
Research
MethodologyAPI
Legal
TermsPrivacySupport
© 2026 Crene, Inc.
Back to clusterPart ofWill the Federal Reserve raise the target range for the federal funds rate at any point during 2026?
Event · ECONOMICS

Will ISM Manufacturing PMI print above 50 for at least three consecutive months in H2 2026?

Resolves Dec 31, 2026
Probability
60%

4-model average

Confidence
LOW

building category history

Stability
—

loading

Models
Diverging

29pt spread

The three supporting readings tell you how much weight to put on the probability: confidence reflects category-level track record, stability tracks how the estimate has moved over time, models shows whether the four agree.

Belief trajectory

Loading belief trajectory...

Per-model probabilities

GPT-4o
65%+5 vs avg

Given the current federal funds target range of 3.50%-3.75% and the market's shift toward potential rate hikes under Kevin Warsh, there is a solid chance for manufacturing activity to stabilize and improve, supporting PMI readings above 50. The labor market shows resilience, while inflation pressures remain a concern; thus, if the Fed opts to raise rates in the upcoming meetings, it could bolster manufacturing sentiment, but ongoing inflationary pressures may temper growth expectations.

Key uncertaintyThe timing and magnitude of the Fed's decision-making in response to any new inflation data could notably impact future PMI trends.
Gemini
60%

The current Federal Funds target range is 3.50%-3.75%, and the Fed under Chair Warsh has signaled a potential shift towards hawkishness, with market pricing favoring holds or hikes over cuts in 2026. This tightening policy environment, coupled with ongoing labor market resilience and a focus on inflation, suggests a continued moderation of economic activity. While a recession is not a certainty, sustained manufacturing expansion above 50 for three consecutive months in H2 2026 would require a significant and persistent acceleration in demand that is less likely given the restrictive monetary policy stance and the Fed's commitment to anchoring inflation expectations. However, the recent "hawkish June pivot" leaves room for interpretation, and the precise impact of Warsh's institutional reset on inflation and growth momentum remains somewhat uncertain, creating a non-negligible chance of stronger manufacturing performance.

Key uncertaintyThe magnitude and persistence of inflationary pressures throughout H2 2026, which will heavily influence the Federal Reserve's decision-making regarding potential rate hikes.
Claude
72%+12 vs avg

The ISM Manufacturing PMI must print above 50 for three consecutive months during H2 2026 (July-December). As of June 18, 2026, the Fed has just held at 3.50%-3.75% with a hawkish pivot, creating a restrictive policy environment that typically suppresses manufacturing activity. However, several factors support manufacturing expansion: (1) the Fed is likely holding rather than hiking further given that rate hikes require explicit threshold breaches at remaining meetings, suggesting policy stabilization; (2) H2 typically shows seasonal strength in manufacturing demand; (3) the current federal funds rate of 3.50%-3.75% is restrictive but not severely so compared to the 5.25%-5.50% peak, allowing some recovery; (4) any three consecutive months during a six-month window (July-December) provides multiple pathways to success. Historical precedent shows that manufacturing PMI often rebounds to above 50 during mid-cycle policy pauses. The main headwind is persistent inflation concerns and the Warsh Fed's institutional reset maintaining hawkish bias, which could keep financial conditions tight. However, the bar is only three consecutive months out of six, not sustained strength.

Key uncertaintyWhether the Warsh Fed actually implements a rate hike (moving the upper bound above 3.75%) before H2, which would significantly tighten financial conditions and reduce the probability of PMI consistently exceeding 50.
GrokGrok
43%-17 vs avg

The ISM PMI has printed below 50 for 35 consecutive months through May 2026 amid 3.50-3.75% policy rates and Warsh's June 17 hawkish pivot, with the new orders sub-index at 47.6 and employment at 48.1 showing no inflection; historical precedent shows only two prior rate-hike cycles (2018, 2022) produced three consecutive >50 prints within six months of the first hike. Warsh's institutional reset and the shift from cut pricing to hold-or-hike pricing in fed funds futures (December 2026 contract at 3.82%) imply tighter financial conditions that typically compress manufacturing through year-end.

Key uncertaintyWhether the September 15-16 FOMC statement signals an explicit 25 bp hike or merely a hawkish hold.
Key disagreementClaude (72%) vs Grok (43%): Different weighting of factors

Resolution criteria

SourceFederal Reserve FOMC statements, implementation notes, SEP, press conference materials, official target range, BLS, BEA, EIA, Treasury, FRED, CME FedWatch, major bank research
CRENE-FED-WARSH-MAC-006Generated Jun 18, 2026