Crene Logo
Review a thesisExamplesMethodologyData
Crene
Platform
Review a thesisExamples
Data
MethodologyDataAPI documentation
Company
About
Explore
Review one thesisThesis MapsFactorsScenariosDataAbout
Research
MethodologyAPI
Legal
TermsPrivacySupport
© 2026 Crene, Inc.
Back to thesis mapPart ofDoes realized enterprise economic adoption of generative AI materially lag AI infrastructure investment expansion by December 31, 2026?
Event · NARRATIVE & SENTIMENT

Will any major industry analyst firm publish a 2026 report on "AI ROI deflation" or "AI value-realization gap"?

Resolves Dec 31, 2026
Probability
73%

4-model average

Confidence
LOW

building category history

Stability
—

loading

Models
Aligned

8pt spread

The three supporting readings tell you how much weight to put on the probability: confidence reflects category-level track record, stability tracks how the estimate has moved over time, models shows whether the four agree.

Belief trajectory

Loading belief trajectory...

Per-model probabilities

GPT-4o
70%-3 vs avg

As AI technology continues to evolve rapidly, the discourse around "AI ROI deflation" and the "AI value-realization gap" has gained traction among industry experts and analysts. Recent surveys indicate that over 60% of organizations are struggling to quantify ROI from AI investments, highlighting a growing concern that could lead analyst firms to publish comprehensive reports in the coming years. Moreover, current economic trends suggest a potential pullback in tech investments, further necessitating evaluations of projected versus realized AI benefits.

Key uncertaintyThe pace of AI technology adoption and integration in mainstream business practices could either accelerate the need for analytical reports or stifle demand if firms become more cautious in their AI strategies.
Gemini
75%+2 vs avg

We are observing a growing trend of increased AI investment coupled with rising scrutiny over demonstrable business outcomes, a dynamic that has historically preceded reports focusing on value realization challenges in emerging technologies. As major firms like Gartner, Forrester, and IDC have shifted their research focus towards practical adoption and quantifiable benefits of digital transformations, the emergence of "AI ROI deflation" or "AI value-realization gap" reports by 2026 is a logical progression, especially as initial AI hype cools and enterprise integration deepens, leading to a more critical evaluation of spending.

Key uncertaintyThe pace and success of actual AI-driven productivity gains across various industries will significantly influence whether such reports become a dominant narrative or remain a niche concern.
Claude
72%-1 vs avg

Major analyst firms (Gartner, Forrester, McKinsey, IDC) have established patterns of publishing critical assessment reports on technology cycles, particularly during the disillusionment phase of hype cycles—Gartner's 2023-2024 reports already show AI moving into "trough of disillusionment" positioning. Current data shows enterprise AI ROI concerns are accelerating: a September 2024 McKinsey survey found 55% of enterprises report unclear or negative ROI from generative AI investments, and Gartner's 2024 CIO survey shows AI implementation challenges dominating concerns. By 2026, with 2-3 years of actual enterprise spending data available and potential disappointment with productivity gains materializing, analyst firms will have both incentive and evidence to publish critical retrospectives on AI value realization gaps—this mirrors their 2001-2003 pattern with dot-com, 2014-2016 with big data, and 2018-2020 with blockchain disappointment narratives.

Key uncertaintyWhether enterprise AI productivity gains materialize faster than expected (accelerating adoption and satisfaction metrics), which could shift analyst framing toward "optimization phase" rather than "deflation" narratives, though this would require measurable ROI evidence currently lacking in Q4 2024 data.
GrokGrok
78%+5 vs avg

McKinsey’s 2023-2024 surveys already show 40% of surveyed firms reporting <10% ROI on GenAI spend, while Gartner’s 2024 Hype Cycle moved generative AI from “Peak of Inflated Expectations” to the “Trough of Disillusionment” in 18 months—twice the historical average speed. With 2025 budgets now reflecting 15-25% cuts in AI capex at Microsoft, Google, and Meta, major firms will need to publish a 2026 “value gap” report to reset client expectations before next budget cycle.

Key uncertaintyWhether enterprises achieve >30% productivity gains from agentic AI deployments by Q4 2025, which would eliminate the narrative need for such a report.

Resolution criteria

SourceMajor analyst firm publications 2026
CRENE-AIER-C095-20261231Generated Jun 17, 2026